Exploring the intersection of teachers’ aims, storytelling practices, and understanding of nature of science in Indian middle school classrooms
Loading...
Date
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Springer Nature
Abstract
Scholarship in science education as well as science education policy in India, including the National Education Policy (2020), emphasizes portraying science as a dynamic, socially embedded endeavor rather than a static body of facts. This study examines the alignment between these policy ideals and classroom reality by exploring three interconnected dimensions of middle school science teaching. We investigated teachers’ pedagogical aims and practices to determine if Nature of Science (NOS) is prioritized and whether current pedagogic practices are conducive to its communication. Specifically, the study investigates the frequency and purpose of storytelling, a strategy identified in literature as a potent tool for humanizing science and conveying its epistemic foundations. Data were collected from 25 teachers across diverse school types in India using semi-structured interviews and a modified SUSSI (Student Understanding of Science and Scientific Inquiry) instrument. Findings reveal that while teachers primarily aim for “scientific literacy” tied to everyday utility, their pedagogical practices—dominated by demonstrations and analogies—rarely explicitly address NOS. Although 85% of teachers utilize stories, these are often spontaneous and lack the epistemic framing necessary to illuminate the tentative and creative nature of scientific discovery. The results suggest a gap between policy-driven NOS goals and teacher enactment, highlighting a need for NOS-specific instructional resources.
Description
Citation
Cultural Studies of Science Education
